| 2008-2009 Mid-Season Rankings | ||||||
| Coed Team Rankings | Women's Team Rankings | |||||
| Rank | School | Rating | Rank | School | Rating | |
| 1 | Texas Wesleyan University | 9468 | 1 | Texas Wesleyan University | 7496 | |
| 2 | Princeton | 8712 | 2 | Rutgers | 6886 | |
| 3 | University of Puerto Rico | 8663 | 3 | Toronto | 6832 | |
| 4 | Columbia | 8647 | 4 | Stanford | 6114 | |
| 5 | University of Ottawa | 8356 | 5 | UC Berkeley | 5719 | |
| 6 | University of Toronto | 8206 | 6 | Columbia | 5125 | |
| 7 | Texas A&M | 7880 | 7 | Mississippi College | 5004 | |
| 8 | Virginia Tech | 7708 | 8 | NYU | 4896 | |
| 9 | Rutgers | 7653 | 9 | Cornell | 4865 | |
| 10 | University of Illinois | 7586 | 10 | Wisconsin-Madison | 4856 | |
| 11 | UT-Austin | 7440 | 11 | UCLA | 4748 | |
| 12 | Stanford | 7412 | 12 | Illinois | 4633 | |
| 13 | University of Wisconsin-Madison | 7356 | 13 | UC San Diego | 4511 | |
| 14 | Duke University | 7342 | 14 | UPENN | 4269 | |
| 15 | Lindenwood University | 7207 | 15 | Georgia Tech | 4132 | |
| 16 | UC-San Diego | 7200 | 16 | SUNY Stonybrook | 4072 | |
| 17 | Georgia Tech | 7085 | 17 | Virginia Tech | 4071 | |
| 18 | UC Berkeley | 7051 | 18 | Georgia State | 3897 | |
| 19 | University of Maryland - College Park | 6995 | 19 | Kansas State | 3752 | |
| 20 | RPI | 6881 | 20 | Tufts | 3685 | |
| 21 | Cornell | 6800 | 21 | Johns Hopkins | 3637 | |
| 22 | Northwestern University | 6799 | 22 | CSU Eastbay | 3612 | |
| 23 | UPenn | 6689 | 23 | The Ohio State | 3488 | |
| 24 | UCLA | 6661 | 24 | Cal Tech | 3461 | |
| 25 | NYU | 6479 | 25 | Ithaca College | 3436 | |
| Other Division Leaders | Other Division Leaders | |||||
| 26 | Mississippi College | 6319 | 26 | RPI | 3140 | |
| 28 | Boston University | 6284 | 27 | Duke | 2969 | |
| 29 | University of Washington | 6270 | 28 | Polytechnic | 2933 | |
| 31 | Wichita State University | 6248 | 29 | Queens | 2594 | |
| 34 | Brown University | 6191 | 30 | Lindenwood | 2478 | |
| 36 | UC Davis | 6046 | 31 | MIT | 1421 | |
| 37 | The Ohio State University | 5965 | ||||
| 42 | University of Minnesota | 5381 | ||||